Affiliate Disclosure: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review – [Definitive Buying Guide]

Whether you are a pro at baseball player or not, if you are familiar with baseball, you must know that a catcher has more responsibilities than any other position player in the field. So you can’t keep the realm in that position by just some cheap uncomfortable gloves. 

That’s why you must need a unique and ideal glove for the position. But unfortunately, there are at least a thousand gloves on the market who claims themselves as the best one. 

But we are all known that it’s not possible and everyone is not as good as their advertisement. That’s why we reviewed 5 best baseball catchers mitts that are personally recommended by professional MLB players. And We want to make you sure that we reviewed these gloves as honestly as possible.

If you are in a hurry and just want to know what the best catchers mitts is, then we recommend the Wilson A2000 Superskin as the best one. 

5 Best Baseball Catchers Mitts – Comparison Chart



Our Rating

Check Price

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review - [Definitive Buying Guide] |

Wilson A2000 SuperSkin Catchers Mitt

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review - [Definitive Buying Guide] |

Rawlings Heart of the Hide Catchers Mitt

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review - [Definitive Buying Guide] |

Akadema AGC98 Catchers Mitt

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review - [Definitive Buying Guide] |

All-Star Pro-Advanced Catchers Mitt

The 5 Best Catchers Mitts Review - [Definitive Buying Guide] |

Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Catchers Mitt

Difference between catchers mitts and gloves

Difference between catchers mitts and gloves info-graphic

The difference between a catcher’s mitt and a glove is that there are not any individual finger components in a mitt. But you can find this in regular baseball gloves. 

The mitt is designed with a unique larger sized pocket, which helps you to trap the ball quickly. You probably noticed that a mitt comes with extra protection and a unique shape. Because it helps pitcher to see a bigger target for throw the ball. And for the pitcher, the much bigger target is, the easier target to throw. And that makes the actual difference from a baseball glove.

But some people called it gloves instead of calling mitts. They know about the difference between these two, but even after that, they prefer to call it gloves. But as you know, it’s not a big deal because they feel comfortable calling it gloves instead of mitts.

History of Catcher’s Mitts

According to Baseball Encyclopedia, the first use of baseball glove was recorded on June 28, 1870. A sportswriter of the Cincinnati Commercial cabled his office that “(Daug) Allison caught today in a pair of buckskin mittens, to protect his hands.” And from this day, baseball mitt started the journey to protect catchers.

In 1890, ex-catcher Harry Decker patented the first official catcher’s glove named it the “Decker Safety Catcher’s Mitt.”

What to look for in the best catchers mitts


What do you think? What catchers mitt do the pros use? As I mentioned before, there are a thousand pieces of baseball mitts in the market. Some of them are best to choose from, but most of them are not as good as promised.

The catcher’s position is the most dangerous position in a baseball field. So you can’t compromise on it at any cost. That’s why you definitely need the ideal mitt for you. But what makes a glove different from others? What are the characteristics of best catchers mitts? 

Well, these things you have to consider before buying the best catcher’s glove. 


As a catcher, you may know that a catcher has to make a lot of quick movements with his catching hand while playing. So definitely you will not choose a too loose or too tight glove which will feel uncomfortable on your hands and wrists.  

So look at the catchers mitt sizing chart, which is based on your age. Make sure that you are going to get that one that fits you perfectly. 


Basically, there are 4 types of materials that can be used in a baseball mitt. Synthetic, mesh-backed, soft leathers, and durable leathers.

If you are here to get a glove for your children, we recommend you go for a synthetic glove. Because it’s lightweight and more inexpensive than others, which made it ideal for children. But the problem is it will not give you an excellent service for a long period of time. 

Mesh backed gloves are very comfortable to wear. And it’s lightweight than other leather catchers mitt. But the cons are that they are not much durable as other leather gloves. 

Soft leathers are good because of its comfortable body. And you don’t need to break in these gloves because it’s not as hard as durable leather. These types of gloves are not much heavier, but it maintains its durability in a good way. The problem is it will not hold up for a long time as synthetic gloves. But it’s not expensive. 

Durable leathers are my favorites. Just not me, most of the professional and serious players recommend these gloves as the best. May they be expensive and heavier, but it’s the most durable materials for a glove. It has the most padding, and when you are going to catch a baseball with them, you will get a sweet, crisp popping sound from it. And it’s worth it. 


Closed or open webbing. Every baseball catcher’s mitt has one of those kinds of webbing. Closed webbing gloves are more durable than open one. And it will give you excellent performance for a long period of time. By the way, you will be happy to know that there are not many open webbing gloves in the market. By any chance, if you want any open webbing gloves, then you have to order them to customize as your preference. 


Catcher’s position is toughest than any other position in the field. You need to catch every ball coming toward your hand while protecting the body. If you wear a glove that has a weak amount of padding, it can hurt you in a bad way. For preventing yourself from injury, try to choose a glove with proper padding. 


As we mentioned before in the sizing part, a catcher’s mitt should perfectly fit your hand at any cost. Because no matter how a durable glove is, it will be a hell product if it doesn’t fit in your hands and wrists. 

But we know everyone’s hand isn’t in the same shape. That’s why we need to adjust these gloves for each character. And you can adjust these gloves by tightening or loosening the laces of the glove. Try to find a catcher’s mitt, which is adjustable because you really need to customize its fits for different people.


Well. Who doesn’t like to get a long-time warranty on his product? Everyone loves it, including me. If the question comes about the warranty, we first have to know the answer to this question: “why do you need a glove?” Probably you are purchasing the glove for solving some specific problem of your position. 

So you must have the intention of causing the problem with it. If it doesn’t maintain your criteria, then you should back it to the manufacturer. Otherwise, it will be a loss product for your money. Try to purchase one of those that have a long-lasting warranty. And that will be bang for the buck to you. 


To be honest, I don’t exactly believe that just good brands always make the best. There are some underrated brands that actually manufacture good mitts. Some of the famous baseball mitt manufacturer brands are:

  • Wilson
  • Rawlings
  • All-star
  • Mizuno
  • Nokona
  • Easton
  • Marucci

But we also love brands like Akadema, Louisville Slugger, and few more. They also manufacture good quality gloves and mitts. But they are not popular like those following. 

If you ask from us, then our opinion is, you should look for quality instead of a brand. Because you will use the glove, not the brand. 

1. Wilson A2000 SuperSkin (Champion in Overall)


Not just first on our list, it’s the first choice of 80% professional and serious catchers. Do you want a glove that is best at leather construction? Done! Best at comfort? Done! Best at long-lasting durability? Done!! Overall do you want a glove that gives you a high-end performance for a long period of time? Well, your search ends here.

Introducing the best catchers glove of the year “Wilson A2000 Superskin”. You have to love every feature of this fantastic baseball catchers mitt. First talks about its strong construction. This amazing mitt is made of pro stock leather, which is the most famous catchers mitt material in the whole world for its quality.

This pro stock leather assures you long-lasting high-end performance for years. You may think it’s a glove that will be heavy to weight because of its durability. But we are extremely sorry to say that it’s not. It’s twice as strong as regular leather, but it’s half of the weight. 

You will love its comfortability for sure. Wilson used the Drilex wrist lining to keep your hand cool and dry while playing for hours. I love the lacing of this glove. Strong, perfectly timed, and guaranteed for a couple of years. Ease to use, comfortable padding, high-quality leather, and unbreakable construction made it a must-have glove if you are a serious catcher. The best part is it comes with 12 months full money refund warranty. If you don’t like it, ask for a refund without any hesitation.

Things that Wilson A2000 SuperSkin could improve on

Some of the customers complained that the price is a little bit higher than the other. But you should know that the better thing comes at a high price.

Another thing is that this catcher’s mitt is only for the professional and serious player. So it requires a professional level of a break-in. If you don’t know how to break in the glove in the right way, then you should look for someone who can do it properly.

  • Extended palm
  • Top-Notch leather
  • Durable
  • Light-weight
  • Drilex wrist lining
  • Pro level of comfort
  • Classy looks
  • As good as promised
  • High range of price
  • Requires proper break-in from an experienced hand

2. Rawlings Heart of the Hide (Runner Up)


Do you need a glove that provides you with durability, protection, and comfort in a package? Then this Rawlings Heart of the Hide is just for you. This glove is prized by professional league level players worldwide for its quality and longevity.

Rawlings catchers mitts are the biggest competitor of Wilson catchers mitts in the durability section. This lightweight glove is made of pro stock leather, which made itself the biggest competitor of Wilson A2000. If you are a fan of MLB, you probably noticed that many catchers using this as their favorite mitts. 

This glove has thumb sleeves, deep pockets and comes with a perfect design. And we believe that it will take your experience level into the next stage. Another good thing is that it has an adjustable strap for making sure that fits with your hands perfectly. 

Specially made to graving high speedy balls that are straightly coming from the bat. Laces, padding, bonding, and construction are beast in their own position. This glove comes with a color variation. You can choose any of them, depending on your wish. (Actually, I will love to pick the Black/Black mesh – Yadier Molina Model one for myself)

Things that Rawlings Heart of the Hide could improve on

Like the first one, this is a professional level glove, and it comes in a medium price range. The truth is that if you want to take something good, then you have to spend some high. And the feature will definitely be worth it.

Another thing is that it comes with 40% of a break-in from the manufacturer. So you will need to break in the other 60% of the glove. Again we warn you that not to break in the wrong way. It will hurt you because it’s not an inexpensive glove to buy.

  • Pro stock leather
  • Durable
  • Adjustable strap
  • Many color option
  • It Will last for years
  • Lightweight
  • The high price might not be affordable for everyone
  • Only for professionals

3. Akadema AGC98 (Inexpensive Killer)


This glove is specially made for those who want the best glove at a budget-friendly price. This glove is exclusively designed by legend catcher Gary Carter. I love the design of this glove. It has a 32’’ inch circumference praying mantis pattern to provide you maximum area for catching the ball. This fantastic mitt comes with a deep pocket so that you will never lose control over it.

This Akadema youth catchers mitt gives you a sweet, crisp sound when the ball hits it just right. And you will love this. No matter you are right-handed or left, both orientations are available for this glove. The back construction is made by high-quality extra light Akadema leather. This lightweight glove will not cost you a hundred dollars for itself. 

If I have to be honest about it, this will be an ideal choice for youth. But I will not recommend this glove to you if you’re an adult league level player. And the other thing is, there is not any variation of color. So if you are a newbie in baseball and trying to find something at a low price, this fantastic catcher’s mitt is just for you. 

  • Durable
  • High-quality Akadema leather
  • Lightweight
  • Inexpensive
  • Last for years
  • Best for youth
  • No color variation

4. All-Star Pro-Advanced (Choice of Pro)


No catching task is too tough or too hard for the All-Star Pro- Advanced baseball catcher’s mitt. Everyone likes it for its quality. That’s why it does not have any single one or two-star review on Amazon. We picked this as 4th choice of this list. But being honest, I hated to do that. It’s just not named as all-star advanced, it’s way more advanced than any other glove in the market. 

It’s an adjustable glove. So you don’t need to worry about its fitting. All-star catchers mitts used soft tan leather palm on their construction for a break in quickly. Some customers complained that this glove is a little bit tough to break in, but it fits great. And it will be worth your wait for sure. 

This glove has a good looking design. As the pocket of the glove is made of soft tan palm leather. It will provide you proper protection to your hand years after year. Overall, it will be an ideal choice for you if you are a serious player and trying to do something biggest in baseball.

  • Durable
  • US grade rawhide lacing
  • Adjustable 
  • Soft tan leather palm
  • Last for a long time
  • Come as described
  • High price
  • Requires time for break-in

5. Mizuno Prospect GXC105 (For Little Champ)


Do you want a perfect glove at a budget-friendly price for the young member of your family? Are you trying to find a durable glove that requires no break-in time while maintaining its quality? Then this glove is just for you. It’s a perfect glove for 10-15 years, old players, with average-sized hands. 

The glove comes with a World-class Para shock palm pad for providing you the outstanding protection. This material is prized for its comfortability. On every Mizuno catchers mitts, there is a feature called PowerClose Technology. And this helps the younger player to close the mitt easily while catching the ball.

The Mizuno prospect is a lightweight and adjustable glove. It will fit on your young buddy’s hand comfortably. This fantastic will not cost you a high price, and that can be a deal maker for you. 

  • Budget-friendly
  • No break-in time
  • Para shock palm pad
  • Game-ready out of the box
  • Leather is soft
  • Lightweight
  • Power Close technology
  • Just for beginner


If you need an all-rounder feature-packed baseball catchers mitt, then the Wilson A2000m SuperSkin baseball glove is our top pick. It’s comfortable, lightweight looks classy and comes with top-notch leather. This is not a glove for using one time. You can count the glove for years. It just needs a proper break-in, and that’s it. If you need to know how to break in a baseball glove professionally then you can watch this video:

Once you’re done, It’s ready to give you a high-class performance for a long time. If you are aiming to play baseball seriously, then this glove is waiting for you. Otherwise, you can go for the Akadema AGC98.

And keep in mind that every glove of this review comes with a money-back guaranty. If anything doesn’t match with your criteria, then ask for a refund to manufacture without any hesitation. 

Oh, do you need some oil for a good break-in? Check this article if you want to know about the best baseball oil for your catchers glove. It’s FREE!!

About Jason Gray

Leave a Reply

Related Posts