Best softball gloves don’t come cheap, and those that come cheap aren’t good at all! If you too believe it, then the below-mentioned gloves will surely change your mind.
No doubt, a softball glove is an essential piece of equipment, but does that mean you should spend more than a hundred bucks on one? Well, no!
While searching for the best softball gloves under $100, I came across numerous high-quality gloves loved by infielders and outfielders, whether you play fastpitch or slowpitch softball.
So, I’ve picked five of them to help you choose an amazing yet cheap softball glove. I also went back through this list in 2026 and re-checked every price, because a $99 glove has a way of creeping past $100 the second a brand does a model refresh. Every glove below is still comfortably under that cap. The post even covers a quick buying guide to help first-time buyers choose the right glove.
Top 5 Best Softball Gloves Under $100
These are the top budget softball gloves that are inexpensive but will enhance your performance for sure. All the gloves I’ve reviewed below are comfortable, durable, and belong to the best brands out there.
1. Rawlings Renegade Slowpitch Softball Glove – Best Overall
If you came here looking for the top quality slowpitch softball glove, have a look at this one. Made with a leather palm and a lightweight mesh back, the glove gives you a classic feel without the classic price tag.
Rawlings rates the break-in at around 10 hours, which is realistic. It’s not a 90% factory break-in glove, but it softens up fast once you start playing catch with it.
Ideal for competitive and recreational gameplay alike, the glove features a basket web system, so you can catch flying balls with ease.
Taking the glove on and off is easy, thanks to the adjustable Velcro strap and Neo-Flex back. The materials are durable enough that the glove holds its shape season after season.
Cushioned palm padding takes the sting out of a hard-hit ball. The pocket is deep and flexible, so you get sure catch control instead of the ball popping back out.
Overall, if you need a sturdy, comfortable slowpitch glove that won’t push your budget anywhere near $100, the Rawlings Renegade is my top pick.
More Details:
- Material: Leather Palm with Mesh Back
- Hand Orientation: Right Hand Throw (Left Hand Throw also available)
- Closure System: Adjustable Velcro Strap
- Webbing: Basket Web System
- Size: 13 inch (12, 12.5, 14, and 15 inch also available)
2. Wilson Siren Fastpitch Softball Glove – Most Loved Softball Glove
Here’s your favorite brand Wilson with a fastpitch infield glove that’s fairly cheap and has everything you need. It’s built with top-grain leather, so it’s a bit heavier than an all-synthetic glove, but it holds its shape better over time.
The Siren is popular with fastpitch infielders and pitchers because the closed web pattern helps you hide the ball from the batter. It’s easy to break in and gives you a comfortable, game-ready fit right away.
I loved the Quick-Fit wrist strap that helps you adjust the glove’s grip in seconds. The leather shell also absorbs the impact of a hard-hit ball nicely.
As a result, you get plenty of room to move your fingers, which helps with agility on the field, and it’s a solid option if you’re on the smaller-handed side too, since it runs in true-to-size youth and adult fastpitch sizing.
The leather isn’t the most breathable material, but Wilson designs the lining to keep sweat from becoming a problem mid-game.
This infield glove has a classy design and offers a comfortable, secure fit.
Lastly, it’s a lightweight leather glove you can wear to unleash your performance on the field. The white, purple, and seafoam color combination looks great, and you get a genuinely well-priced fastpitch glove out of it.
More Details:
- Material: Top-Grain Leather
- Hand Orientation: Left/Right Hand
- Closure System: Quick-Fit Adjustable Wrist Strap
- Webbing: Closed Web System
- Size: 11.5, 12, 12.5 inches
3. Rawlings RSB Adult Slowpitch Softball Glove Series – Best Value for Money
RSB Adult Slowpitch Softball Glove is an excellent, wallet-friendly choice by Rawlings. It has a basket web that provides a secure catch while helping conceal the ball from the hitter.
Also, the glove has a shallower pocket, so it helps in transferring the softball quickly, making it great for infielders.
Made with an all-leather palm, the glove is highly durable and feels great on the hand. It protects your hand well from the impact of a hard-hit ball.
The padded finger linings offer more comfort while your fingers get enough space to bend freely.
Custom-fit for every softball player, the glove features a Neo-Flex back and Velcro strap. You get a snug fit with the Rawlings RSB Adult Slowpitch Softball Glove Series, without the hassle of constant readjusting.
The glove looks great and has a wide, deep pocket. Breaking in this glove isn’t much of a task, and it comes with a good amount of factory break-in already done.
This is one of the most affordable gloves on this list, typically running well under $60, and it’s held up as a reliable pick for anyone new to slowpitch who doesn’t want to overspend before they know if they’ll stick with the game.
Lastly, the glove has the right weight to give you good balance and mobility while catching flying balls.
More Details:
- Material: Leather
- Hand Orientation: Left/Right Hand
- Closure System: Velcro Adjustable Strap
- Webbing: Basket Web System
- Size: 12, 13, 14 inch
4. Franklin Sports Field Master Softball Glove – Best Versatile Glove
If you don’t mind wearing a chunky tan glove to the softball field, have a look at the Franklin Sports Field Master. It’s also the cheapest glove on this list by a wide margin, which makes it a smart pick for a backup glove or a beginner.
This glove is another name for comfort, thanks to the inner padding and thick fingers with more room.
The glove looks great and is made using synthetic leather, so forget about the hassles of a difficult break-in.
Furthermore, it mimics the properties of real leather. With a built-in contour fit system, the glove offers more comfort.
The customizable thumb adjustment technology helps you grab the catch without a miss. The hand-formed pocket provides maximum comfort while rewarding you with better balance and stability.
This glove features a big closed pocket that helps you grab the catch quickly while transferring the softball to another player.
The frontal side of the palm is also synthetic leather, but it does the job pretty well by absorbing the impact.
To sum up, this is a fantastic inexpensive softball glove you can wear during practice sessions and tournaments. Make sure to adjust the lace properly so the glove stays securely in place.
More Details:
- Material: Synthetic Leather
- Hand Orientation: Left/Right Hand
- Closure System: Velcro Adjustable Strap
- Webbing: Basket Web System
- Size: 14 Inches
5. Wilson A360 Slowpitch Softball Glove – Best Wilson Softball Glove
Softball and baseball players love Wilson gloves, quality and comfort being the top reasons. If you want a comfortable, budget-friendly slowpitch glove, the Wilson A360 is a solid choice. If you want to dig deeper into the whole A360 lineup, I’ve reviewed Wilson’s slowpitch gloves separately.
The CarbonLite shell is a versatile choice and rewards the player with the ability to play all over the field in different positions.
Furthermore, the glove feels comfortable, and you get plenty of room for your fingers.
Since it’s built with a synthetic shell rather than full leather, it’s easy to break in, and you can head to the field right away with the glove in your hand.
The closed V-laced web gives you an edge while catching hard-hit balls.
Moreover, you can hide the ball’s position from the hitter, thanks to the closed web design. Wilson designed this glove to hold up over a full season of recreational play.
That said, it’s not going to outlast a premium all-leather glove like the Renegade above if you’re playing several times a week.
The closure strap is Velcro, and you can easily adjust the tightness for a snug fit that keeps the glove in place.
Lastly, this inexpensive softball glove is a great option for recreational use and practice sessions, and it’s a name you can trust if you’d rather stick with a brand you already know.
More Details:
- Material: Synthetic (CarbonLite Shell)
- Hand Orientation: Right Hand (Left Hand Throw also available)
- Closure System: Velcro Adjustable Strap
- Webbing: Closed V-Lace Web System
- Size: 13, 14 Inches
Buying Guide – What to Look for When Buying the Best Softball Glove under $100?
Every softball glove is different and contains multiple elements, which can affect the player’s performance. Here are a few things you need to look for in a softball glove before buying and playing with it.
Fastpitch or Slowpitch?
Before you even look at material or webbing, figure out which game you’re actually playing. Fastpitch and slowpitch softball gloves aren’t identical, and buying the wrong style can leave you with a pocket that’s too deep or too shallow for the pitching speed and ball movement you’re actually dealing with.
Material
Start by checking the material. Softball gloves come in a variety of leathers, and each material has its own pros and cons.
Synthetic Leather
Synthetic leather gloves are the cheapest and ideal for younger or newer players. The material is durable enough for recreational play and rewards you with solid performance for the price.
Steer Hide
This leather is heavy but offers outstanding durability. Only a handful of brands offer softball gloves made using this leather, and they’re generally on the expensive side, so you won’t find many steer hide gloves under $100.
Cowhide
Perfect for serious softball players, gloves made with cowhide leather break in fairly easily. So you don’t have to struggle with the glove.
Moreover, the material feels premium and gives you enough flexibility to move your fingers without compromising agility.
Full-grain Leather
The classic softball gloves come in full-grain leather. They’re heavy, stiff, and require more time to break in. You can expect these gloves to enhance your performance once broken in successfully.
Webbing
Next comes the webbing. It’s a huge part of the softball glove that connects the fingers to the thumb. You’ll find two main options, open and closed.
Softball pitchers often consider gloves with closed webbing to conceal the ball from the batter. However, first base players should consider open web because it helps them transfer the ball easily while catching a flying softball.
The size of the glove’s pocket depends on your position. Softball gloves with shallower pockets are great for middle infielders, whereas deeper pockets suit outfielders best.
Pockets in these gloves are usually bigger than baseball glove pockets because of the bigger size of the softball.
Wrist Strap
The wrist strap helps the player get a snug fit. The strap can either be elastic or Velcro, depending on the glove and brand. Some softball gloves even come with a buckle or D-ring system.
I love Velcro strap gloves since they’re convenient, and you can easily adjust the grip during gameplay.
Break-in Period
Never overlook the break-in period when buying softball gloves. Most of these inexpensive gloves are made using synthetic leather, and that material is easy to break in.
However, if you choose real leather, make sure you budget some time for breaking in the glove.
Size and Hand Orientation
If a glove doesn’t fit properly, it can’t offer comfort or improve your gameplay. The standard size in these gloves is usually around 12 inches, but I’d walk through how to size a softball glove properly before you buy, since sizing runs differently by position and by brand.
Make sure to choose the glove based on its hand orientation too. For your ease, I’ve listed the size and hand orientation with every glove above.
Another thing to remember: softball and baseball gloves are sized a bit differently. So don’t just buy a softball glove based on a baseball glove’s size.
Wrapping It Up
I’ve reviewed the best softball gloves under $100, so you can quickly make a choice. Just make sure to choose the right material and size to improve your performance with the new glove.
Whether you’re a young player or an adult, you can check out these gloves to play softball without stretching your budget. The number one glove in this list is the Rawlings Renegade Slowpitch Softball Glove.
It’s a genuinely durable leather-palmed glove that stays comfortably under $100 and holds up well throughout the season.
With 4 years of Division II experience, a .272 career batting average, .410 on-base percentage, and 7 home runs, I’m now in my fifth season. I’ve played baseball since age 3, alongside future MLB Draft picks, and I aim to pursue a career in baseball professionally, be it playing, coaching, or scouting.