I get asked about the Wilson A900 first base mitt more than almost any other glove on this site. It’s been a go-to pick for first basemen since it launched back in 2018, and even though Wilson has since moved on to newer gear, plenty of players are still hunting one down secondhand or on clearance. There are tons of first base mitts on the market, and not every one of them holds up in every condition. So is the Wilson A900 still worth chasing down? Let’s get into my full Wilson A900 first base mitt review, including the pros, the cons, and where you can still find one in 2026. If you’re new to the position, it also helps to understand the difference between a baseball mitt and a glove before you shop.
Quick spoiler: in my experience, the Wilson A900 is still a genuinely good first base mitt, and it holds up well against pricier options like the Rawlings Pro Preferred. Current Rawlings Pro Preferred first base mitts routinely retail for $300 or more, while the A900 sold in the $55 to $90 range when it was in regular production. That’s a massive gap for a mitt that gets the job done at first base. Let’s start the review with what it’s actually made of.
Wilson A900 First Base Mitt Review
Is the Wilson A900 First Base Mitt Still Available in 2026?
Here’s the honest update before you go looking for one: Wilson doesn’t list a dedicated A900 first base mitt on its own site anymore. The current A900 lineup is built around Pedroia Fit infield gloves, an outfield glove, and a utility glove, not a first base mitt. Several retailers, including JustBallGloves, list the original WTA09RB18BM12 and WTA09RB20BM12 first base mitt models as discontinued, and other sellers show them as out of stock more often than not.
That doesn’t mean it’s impossible to find. Leftover stock still shows up on Amazon, eBay, and secondhand marketplaces like SidelineSwap from time to time. I’m keeping this review live because it’s still one of the better options if you can track one down, and because it’s a useful benchmark against what’s currently on shelves. If you’d rather buy something Wilson is actively producing today, skip down to my picks at the end.
Materials And Construction
The A900 is built from Wilson’s Pro-grade leather shell, which is noticeably more durable than what you get on entry-level mitts. It’s designed to soak up the impact from hard-hit balls and scorching line drives coming straight from the bat without breaking down over a season.
The lightweight double palm construction makes it easy to use for players of most ages and skill levels. On the outside, Wilson used a full leather lining instead of a cheaper synthetic, and the laces are strong enough to last a couple of seasons of regular use without needing a relace. Overall, I’d give it a 9/10 for materials and construction.
Design
The low-profile heel on the front of this mitt gives you flexibility without sacrificing structure, which matters when you’re stretching for a throw in the dirt. I still love the color scheme too. The whole mitt is a dark brown that looks a lot like a Cadbury bar, with the laces, logo, and lining picked out in white, which makes it stand out on the field.
This mitt uses a single post web design, which is a common choice for first base mitts because it helps you scoop and secure the ball with a bit more ease than a closed web. The embossed logo gives it a premium look whenever you wear it. It doesn’t add any real performance benefit, but I like it because it just looks sharp. Overall, I’d score the design an 8/10.
Hand Variations
Most baseball gloves come with only one throwing hand option. Gloves for lefties tend to be harder to find because left-handed throwers make up a smaller share of the player pool, so a lot of brands don’t bother stocking both.
The Wilson A900 first base mitt was made in both right hand throw and left hand throw versions, so lefties weren’t left out. That’s a real point in its favor, and it’s one of the reasons I still recommend tracking one down if you can find your size and hand orientation in stock. Overall, that’s a 10/10 for hand variations, no way around it.
Ease Of Use
The Wilson A900 first base mitt is a comfortable, low-maintenance choice for players who don’t want to spend weeks breaking in a stiff piece of leather. One of my favorite things about it is the sharp, crisp pop it makes on a catch. I’m a bit of an ASMR fan, so that little detail goes a long way for me.
First base means long games in the sun, and sweaty hands can mess with your grip at the worst possible moment. The soft straps on this mitt let some air through and help keep your hand from getting swampy during a long afternoon game. Overall, I’d give it 8.5/10 for usability.
Should I Buy This?
If you can still find the Wilson A900 first base mitt in your size, hand, and price range, yes, I’d buy it. It’s a well-built, no-frills mitt that competes with options costing two or three times as much, like the Rawlings Pro Preferred.
Just know you’re shopping the secondhand and leftover-stock market at this point, since Wilson isn’t actively producing it anymore. Check current listings on Amazon, and keep an eye on retailers like eBay and SidelineSwap for gently used pairs. Wilson originally backed the A900 with its standard 12-month limited warranty, so if you’re buying a new-in-box unit, it’s worth asking the seller whether that coverage still applies.
If you’d rather buy something Wilson currently has in production, check out my Wilson A1000 glove review for a budget-friendly alternative, or my Wilson A2K vs Rawlings Pro Preferred comparison if you’re ready to spend more for a higher-end mitt.
With 4 years of Division II experience, a .272 career batting average, .410 on-base percentage, and 7 home runs, I’m now in my fifth season. I’ve played baseball since age 3, alongside future MLB Draft picks, and I aim to pursue a career in baseball professionally, be it playing, coaching, or scouting.